"Suburbs are all about the weekend business. Totally different." Derek Axelrod said that to Newsday in March, when he closed the Roslyn location of his Manhattan restaurant TBar. He was explaining why a concept that runs on weekday city traffic had a hard time at 1363 Old Northern Boulevard. His explanation also describes the newer places along the same blocks. The restaurants that have done well in Roslyn come from the city but are built for weekend tables, neighborhood prices and diners who walk in. This year's openings follow that pattern closely, and they line up neatly for a holiday weekend when the house is full.
Why city restaurants keep choosing Roslyn
Newsday has called Roslyn "long a testing ground for city restaurant expansion," and the record goes back further than most people would guess. In a Newsday piece on why New York City restaurants keep coming to Roslyn, the starting point is Il Mulino on Northern Boulevard, which opened in 2004. Co-owner Brian Galligan, who lived in Oyster Bay Cove, told the paper that Roslyn pulls "from Locust Valley, Roslyn, Manhasset, Great Neck and the towns off Northern Boulevard." He added, "Because of the highway, you get the city crowd, the Queens crowd and the larger North Shore crowd."
The next wave followed its own regulars out of the city. Jacopo Giustiniani of SA Hospitality, the group behind Sant Ambroeus and Felice, told Newsday that many of his Upper East Side customers were in their 30s, starting families and moving to the Island. "Let's go where all of my customers are moving," he said. Felice opened at 1382 Old Northern Blvd. in 2022, in a space that had been Friend of a Farmer two decades earlier and had sat empty since. According to Newsday, it has more frontage on the pond than any other restaurant in the village. "When I saw the pond, I fell in love," Giustiniani said.
Pietro's, a Manhattan restaurant founded in 1932, opened on Main Street on Nov. 16, 2023, in the former Jolly Fisherman space at 25 Main St. These restaurants came to Roslyn for its diners, and in Felice's case for its scenery. Galligan and Giustiniani both described Roslyn as the place their customers already lived.
1363 Old Northern Boulevard, the corner to watch
Long Island Wave called 1363 Old Northern Boulevard "Roslyn's most churned-through corner." It was MP Taverna, chef Michael Psilakis's modern Greek tavern, for years. Roslyn Social, a sports-bar concept, took over in 2019, Brass Swan followed in 2022, and TBar arrived in 2024. The Wave describes it as a large space on a prominent village street, and every new operator steps into the expectations left by the one before.
TBar brought its Manhattan menu with it, according to Newsday's account of the closing: a 40-ounce porterhouse, herb-grilled branzino, soy-wasabi crusted tuna and sushi, along with brick-oven pizza added for Long Island. The next tenant will get a dining room Newsday described as elegant, with a cream palette and a velvet-paneled lounge upstairs.
The next tenant may already be lined up. Long Island Wave reported in September that Vendome Hospitality Group Roslyn LLC was formed in late April and registered at 1363 Old Northern Boulevard. The name matches the company run by brothers Michael and Franco Vendome, who operate Nino's AQ in Astoria and Nino's 46 in the Manhattan theater district. In May 2022 they opened Nino's Beach, a 9,500-square-foot waterfront Mediterranean restaurant at the Safe Harbor marina in Port Washington, where some guests arrive by boat. This group has already run a large room in Nassau County that fills on summer weekends. The Wave made the same point: the operator now reaching for the keys has shown it can run a big room here.
The 2026 arrivals were built for weekends
The places that opened on Old Northern Boulevard this year are a closer match for Axelrod's description of the suburbs.
Mythos Kitchen at 1380 Old Northern Blvd. is the first Long Island location of Mythos, a Flushing restaurant whose flagship has been open 26 years. It was founded by the late Peter Theodoropoulos and is now run by his son Jimmy, who recently moved from Bayside to Glenwood Landing. Newsday reported that his mother, Athina, still runs the Queens location. She bakes the bread every morning at 6 and delivers it to Roslyn, where it comes to the table warm with herbed olive oil.
At Mythos, the menu is set up to bring in neighbors. The $25 lunch includes an appetizer salad, an entree such as pastitsio, moussaka or bifteki with a side, and baklava. On the full dinner menu, lamb chops are $55, branzino is $45 and a mixed grill for two is $85. There is also a steam table of home-cooked dishes ready to take home, which Theodoropoulos told Newsday is "the same concept as Queens." Newsday listed the hours as 11 a.m. to 10 p.m. daily. Takeout from a restaurant open seven days fits the Friday after Thanksgiving, when the leftovers have run out and there are still eight people at the table.
According to Newsday, Mythos is one storefront from PopUp Bagels. The Roslyn Landmark Society announced that PopUp opened at 1388 Old Northern Blvd. on Nov. 15, 2024, as the brand's first Long Island location. The brand started in Adam Goldberg's kitchen and already had locations in Manhattan. PopUp is now two years into its Roslyn run, and a bagel shop is about as weekend-morning a business as there is.
Across the street at 1355 Old Northern Blvd., Ilios Froyo moved into the former Yolo Yogurt space. Owners Andrew and Sophia Quintero built it as a Greek and Cypriot-inspired frozen yogurt shop, and Long Island Press reported in early September that it had recently opened. A few minutes away, at Bryant Plaza, 333 Warner Ave., Pilar Coffee Bar opened in July. Newsday reported that brand owner Steve Giordanella serves coffee, breakfast, lunch and sweets there. Neither shop depends on weekday office crowds.
Twelve seats beneath Okaru
This year's most ambitious opening sits beneath a restaurant from 2025, and it is built around a small, fixed number of seats. Okaru, a modern Japanese restaurant at 1401 Old Northern Blvd., opened in early 2025. Newsday reported that it is a partnership between chef Marc Spitzer, a Plainview native and longtime chef at Manhattan's BONDST, and Roslyn-based real estate developer Noam Shemel.
Downstairs, Koyu opened on Nov. 5. It is a 12-seat omakase counter with an 18-course menu, and Eater NY reports two seatings a night, Thursday through Saturday. Executive sushi chef Bryan Yee also came from BONDST. A three-night week fits Axelrod's description of suburban dining. Koyu sells about two dozen seats a night on the nights people go out, and it stays dark the rest of the week.
A long weekend on Old Northern Boulevard
These openings are all within a short walk, so a Thanksgiving weekend with guests can stay on one stretch of Old Northern Boulevard and Main Street. Start Friday with bagels from PopUp at 1388, then walk them to the pond. For a lunch that feeds everyone without much planning, Mythos at 1380 has the $25 lunch or the steam table for takeout. Felice at 1382, next to Mythos, is the place to sit with a view of the water. Pietro's on Main Street is good for a group that wants an old Manhattan dining room without driving into Manhattan. Kids can walk to Ilios at 1355 for frozen yogurt. If the guests are the kind you plan a Saturday around, Koyu's 12 seats on Friday and Saturday nights are the hardest table in the village to get.
The same blocks carry into December. Thyme, the contemporary American restaurant at 8 Tower Place, takes private holiday bookings through Dec. 20 and serves a Christmas Eve dinner on Dec. 24 with festive specials added to its regular menu, according to its OpenTable listing. If the Grist Mill restoration was part of your fall walks, our earlier look at what's changing inside Roslyn's old buildings covers that side of the village, and our Roslyn neighborhood page has the rest of the area.
Keep an eye on 1363 as well. By Newsday's count, city restaurants have been trying Roslyn for more than twenty years, and the company registered at that address carries the name of a family that has already filled a large room on the North Shore every summer.
Here at Team Knoell, we know Roslyn block by block. If you're curious what a street like Old Northern Boulevard means for your home's value, start with our instant home valuation. We'd be glad to talk it through with you, any time after the leftovers are gone.